Monthly Archives: December 2011

Brooklyn Black Chocolate Stout


I don’t know what it is about the holiday season, but there are so many good beers!   Brooklyn Brewing’s seasonal Imperial Stout, called Black Chocolate Stout is yet another.  At 10% ABV it’s a big, and heavy beer, excellent for the deep winter evenings.  The nose is roasted cocoa, and the middle is sweet with chocolate malt, bitter with coffee, and finished with a warming alcohol and sweet chocolate. The sweet and the bitter notes seem to stand strongly on their own…I would prefer it a bit more if they were blended and balanced each other out a bit better instead, but that aside, this is a good, strong winter stout.

I give it a 4.3 out of 5.

Anchor Christmas Ale


The 2011 version of Anchor Christmas Ale is the 37th version, different every year since Anchor Brewing started making it in the holiday season of 1975.   They won’t say what malts or hops are in it, and I’m not good enough to discern them on my own, but based on the taste profile I’d call it a winter warmer.  It’s a medium to heavy bodied ale, with roasted chocolate on the nose, chocolate and cherry in the middle and a sweet fruity finish.  I think they’ve come up with a winner in this year’s recipe.

I give it a 4.6 out of 5.

Sierra Nevada Celebration Ale


It’s Boxing Day, which calls for a…Holiday IPA?   Well, I guess it does!   Sierra Nevada Brewing Co. calls Celebration Ale a special holiday ale, and an IPA featuring the first hops of the growing season.  I call it the very definition of a classic IPA, with fresh pine scents, and a hoppy bitter middle with some citrus zest and more pine in the finish.  Holiday special or not, this is a truly stellar IPA.

I give it a 4.7 out of 5.

Bell’s Christmas Ale


Merry Christmas!  What better treat on Christmas Day than Bell’s Brewery’s Christmas Ale?  Bell’s Christmas Ale is a winter seasonal that is unusual for a holiday beer in that there are no spices at all.  It’s strictly a barley and hops beer, that’s very well balanced with a hit of sweet malt in the middle and bitter hops on the finish. It’s fruity, with orange in the nose, and both orange and cherries in the middle that remind me of a Belgian.  A really outstanding Christmas treat.

I give it a 4.6 out of 5.

Samuel Adams Old Fezziwig Ale


Old Fezziwig Ale is exactly what I think of when I think of a holiday beer.   It’s malty and spicy, with caramel and chocolate notes accentuated by cinnamon, ginger, and orange peel.   It’s not overly sweet though, and in fact it leans overall definitively towards the bitter side.  This is an excellent beer to relax with late on Christmas Eve, and one of my favorites from Samuel Adams.

I give it a 4.3 out of 5.

Samuel Adams Cherry Wheat


The Boston Beer Company’s Samuel Adams Cherry Wheat ale is a very fruity beer.  It’s less beer with cherry notes (think Belgian ales) than it is cherry juice with some beer mixed into it.  If you like fruit juice, but don’t like beer, this may be a good drink for you.

I give it a 2.7 out of 5.

Kirkland Signature Amber Ale


Getting toward the end of my mixed case of Costco’s white-labeled Kirkland Signature ales brewed for them by the New York Brewing Company.  The amber ale is a bit of an odd one.  The nose has a hint of chocolate, the middle is slightly bitter, and the finish is slightly sweet.  It’s definitely titled toward the malty side.   The flavor profile improves as it warms, and it loses some of the bitterness in the middle. This is an ok beer, but overall, not my favorite in the case.

I give it a 2.9 out of 5.